- Jean W. Ashton, Senior Director, Resources and Programs & Library Director (Emerita), New-York Historical Society
- Barbara Aronstein Black, George Welwood Murray Professor Emerita of Legal History, Dean Emerita, Faculty of Law, Columbia University
- Patricia U. Bonomi, Professor Emerita of History, New York University
- Christopher L. Brown, Professor of History, Columbia University
- Elizabeth M. Nuxoll, former Editor, John Jay Papers
- Jeffrey B. Morris, Professor of Law, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, Touro College
- Jack N. Rakove, William Robertson Coe Professor of History and American Studies, and Professor of Political Science, Stanford University
- Michael T. Ryan, Vice President and Director of the Patricia D. Klingenstein Library, New-York Historical Society
- Herbert E. Sloan, Professor Emeritus of History, Barnard College
- Jennifer E. Steenshorne, former Associate Editor, John Jay Papers